OK before anything else I really should give some more extensive background info. If you read my previous post and the "About Me" section you already have the basic idea. I'm guessing there are loads of people in similar situations and I would love to hear from all of you. Here is my elementary school story.
I went to a very prominent brooklyn yeshiva for elementary school. According to my mother, although i only found out about this recently, I was already getting bad reports from rabbis in the 3rd grade. It's basically because I never had any interest in learning, none whatsoever. Even as a little kid I would ask questions like "What's the point of learning all this stuff?" and, although this may come as a shock to those of you familiar with the yeshiva system, I was never answered. Due to this lack of interest in the material i would never really pay much attention in the judaic studies parts of my day, and seeing as, even waaaay back in like 1st grade, that's the majority of the day, i kinda hated school. The real issues started in 4th grade when we have some government test in all of our general studies subjects. Suffice it to say i did extremely well and thanks to that the yeshiva had me pegged as someone who just didn't care about learning in spite of having ability. Trust me, that is not at all an envyable position to be in. I would flunk farhers with the principle and they would get really upset. I just didn't know what to tell them. My parents just could not fathom why I would get consistently awful reports from rabbis. Things just kinda proceeded like this for a few years having a 95+ avg in "english" and something way below that in "hebrew". Although it did suck wasting most of my days, it really wasn't awful. And then...8th grade happened.
Before I get into how crappy that year was, allow me to go on a slight digression. To greater understand why this was so shocking to my parents you need to understand that I have 2 older brothers who went to the same yeshiva I did who were both adored by their rebbiem (not in that way! although that does seem to be a trend these days). So after getting nothing but good reports for their boys I was really paving a totaly different trail.
8th grade was one of the worst experiences of my life thus far. 1st of all that's the age that your supposed to get "serious" about learning and davening and wearing black hats. Basically when you're supposed to become a "yeshiva bochur". Now, I had an awful, in case you didn't get that I'll repeat it, awful rabbi that year. I couldn't care less about learning and he hated me for it. I will never know why me picked on me so much compared to the other slackers in the class. Maybe I'll do another post detailing the experience but I have loads of memories from 8th grade...none of them good. Then came the day where the asst. principe "caught" me putting on teffilin alone in the class room and davening without a minyan. They started a whole campaign about it. What a tragedy! A boy just a few months after his bar mitzvah already skipping minyan. After that I just stopped davening at all. They gave speeches to the whole school about the importance of davening and blah blah blah. We took 4 big tests in 8th grade 2 regents and 2 gemarah tests. I got the highest mark in my grade on both regents and did amazingly bad on the gemarah tests. To this day i doubt i got a single question right. Oddly, they would have been happier if i would have flunked everything. That was the worst offense I could commit! It showed a lack of caring about learning. Wrong priorities! I was totally confused as a little kid not understanding what I did wrong and why they were so mad at me. If only I knew then what I know know. (Wow amazingly depressing use of cliche! that has got to be worth something as a writer, right?!?) Even at graduation it didn't stop. I don't know if all yeshivas are like this but mine only acknowledged hebrew studies as an accomplishment and I was one of only 3 kids to not receive any award. Out of 75! To not give 3 kids awards is pretty damn stupid. Kids care a whole lot about impressing their families. That lack of caring is still pretty upsetting to think about.
All in all elementary school sucked, but still paled in comparison to the craziness that is yeshiva high school. However, my HS years weren't as bad because I was less confused and had a better understanding of who I was and that most of the stuff they were saying was complete bullshit anyway. But that's for my next post. (which will be coming shortly, sorry bout the narrative like style of these posts just really need to put this stuff on the table before I can talk about anything else)
Trust me, you're not the 1st person to not be a fan of yeshiva/BY, and you won't be the last. Kinda sounds like some of my early years in BY if you ask me. I'm sure a lot of the style people that will read this can have similar experiences to share that would shock you.
ReplyDeletein yeshiva high school I studied secular stuff in the the rabonim's faces even during religious classes. fuck them what they gonna do? XD
ReplyDeleteCongrats! you got the apikoras JP to comment. You made it to the big leagues!
ReplyDeleteOK I guess it's the power rush getting to my head but i removed JP's comments. I just got really irritated by them. Now I'm all for the 1st amendment and free speech but that's just hating for no reason. All views, no matter how ridiculous, are welcome, but anyone that read those comments understands what I mean. I apologize to freedom, but it needed to be done
ReplyDeleteI also hated school, but I didn’t really do well in any subject. English subjects at least were somewhat interesting. I usually spent the first part of the year reading the textbooks and the rest of the year daydreaming. I rarely studied, and managed to just coast by on what I remembered. Hebrew subjects were less interesting, and I never learned to read (well, translate) anywhere near as fluently as I could read English, so I often failed chumash and gemara tests.
ReplyDeleteI spent the school day waiting for the few hours of free time I’d have when I got home. Unfortunately, the bulk of the time I spent in school was wasted.
> Now I'm all for the 1st amendment and free speech
That only applies to the government. For your own publication you can whatever rules you want. Discussions with people who disagree are great, but JP isn’t interested in discussions. There’s something wrong with that man. All he’s interested in is sex.
@G*3
ReplyDeleteI know i was kinda kidding about the first amendment. and Amen on that JP issue...hopefully the last we see of him
You'll still see me laughing at you while you burn in hell forever.
ReplyDeletehttp://jewishphilosopher.blogspot.com/2009/06/jewish-heretics.html
I can so totally relate! I, too, did really well in secular studies and did very poorly in the Hebrew studies. It placed a stigma on me, as well and I suffered for it.
ReplyDeleteI look forward to reading more of your story!
Jesus, it's like I wrote this post myself. The only major difference is that my turning point was 9th grade, not 8th. For all I know we went to same yeshiva. It sure sounds like it.
ReplyDeleteI figured that there are tons if people who have had very similar experiences in the yeshiva/BY world.
ReplyDeleteOK is there anyone else that uses blogger that can help me with something? It's really annoying deleting all JP's retarded comments so...is there a way to block someone from commenting to begin with?
ReplyDelete